It Was a Grim Year for Cops, but Was 2021 the Worst Ever?

Webp.net-resizeimage - 2022-01-19T150840.854

Fellow Dallas Police officers escort the body of Officer Mitchell Penton, who was struck and killed by a driver on Feb. 13, 2021. Dallas Police Department photo.

Stalked by the deadly COVID-19 virus and rocked by a rise in ambush slayings, 2021 was a grim year for law enforcement officers nationwide. But are the headlines trumpeting it as the deadliest year since the Great Depression right?

Marcia Ferranto, the CEO of the nonprofit National Law Enforcement Officers Memorial Fund, believes 2021 was the most lethal year for law enforcement since 1930. In a preliminary report analyzing the fatalities, her researchers counted 458 officers killed in the line of duty last year.

Following the slaying of a Cleveland cop by an alleged carjacker and other deaths, however, the ultimate number of police officers killed doing their jobs in 2021 is poised to rise to 511.

“The year 2021 will go down as the year of the most line-of-duty fatalities since 1930 due to the Covid-19 pandemic and increases in traffic fatalities and firearms ambushes,” Ferranto said in a prepared statement.

But some criminologists aren’t so sure.

grim year for cops police ambush

Ambushed Dec. 16, 2021, by gunmen while she sat in her patrol car, Baltimore Police Officer Keona Holley was laid to rest Jan. 11, 2022, in Maryland. Office of Gov. Larry Hogan photo.

Ambushed Dec. 16, 2021, by gunmen while she sat in her patrol car, Baltimore Police Officer Keona Holley was laid to rest on Jan 12, 2022, in Maryland. Office of Governor Larry Hogan photo.

Cody Jorgensen, an assistant professor at Boise State University, told Coffee or Die Magazine more information is needed. He worries that calling 2021 the most dangerous year for cops in nine decades might come off as “rather misguided and even maybe a little disingenuous.”

Part of the problem stems from reports created during the Great Depression.

“I don’t put too much stock in data from the 1930s. The accuracy of records that old are questionable,” he said. “So, I can’t say with confidence anything about comparing the hazards of policing today to that of the ’30s. However, more recent data are more reliable. COVID aside, it is much safer being a police officer today than it was back in the late ’80s and early ’90s when crime peaked in this country.”

So is 2021 an anomaly? Jorgensen agrees that 2021 was a terrible year for officers, but it arrived during “a historically safe period for police.”

“During that time, we experienced comparatively low crime rates,” he said.

police officers during the Great Depression

Minneapolis police officers battle striking truck drivers in 1934, near the depths of the Great Depression. National Archives photo.

Minneapolis Police officers battle striking truck drivers in 1934, near the depths of the Great Depression. National Archives photo.

Tracking both the annual violent crime rate and officer fatalities over time, Thaddeus Johnson, an assistant professor at Georgia State University, believes that naming a year as the “deadliest” or “most dangerous” doesn’t really tell a full story about policing.

“I think if you choose either one, you paint an incomplete picture,” said Johnson, who suspects 2021 might end up being an outlier.

“We tend to look at the count and we really can’t only look at that. We have to look at the rate as well, because if you see the rate, the rate has been declining precipitously over time even though the numbers have stayed around the same — like population, more law enforcement officers, and things like that,” said Johnson, who spent a decade as a ranking Memphis Police officer before he became a criminologist.

Chicago Officer Ella French

Officer Ella French with the Chicago Police Department was shot and killed Aug. 7, 2021, during a traffic stop. Chicago Police Department photo.

Officer Ella French with the Chicago Police Department was shot and killed Saturday, Aug. 7, 2021, during a traffic stop. Chicago Police Department photo.

Scholars recorded 312 officers killed in the line of duty in 1930. Some of those deaths might’ve been tied to lingering effects from the influenza epidemic of 1928-29, but perhaps not to the same extent that COVID-19 threatens officers today.

In 2021, 301 officers died from COVID-19, according to the National Law Enforcement Officers Memorial Fund’s preliminary findings. That’s a 65% hike from the previous year, and currently COVID-19 remains the leading killer of cops nationwide.

But subtracting out COVID-19 deaths and then comparing the rest of the fatalities with the estimated number of officers on the job reveals about a .03% line-of-duty death rate for all officers, roughly the same as in 2011.

By including COVID-19 deaths, however, the police officer fatality rate doubles.

New Hampshire truck collision

New Hampshire State Trooper Staff Sgt. Jesse Sherrill was killed in a collision between his cruiser and a semitrailer truck on Oct. 28, 2021. Manchester Police Department photo.

New Hampshire State Trooper Staff Sgt. Jesse Sherrill was killed in a collision with a semitrailer truck early Thursday, Oct. 28, 2021. Manchester Police Department photo.

The National Law Enforcement Officers Memorial Fund relies on a task force to determine whether a COVID-19 mortality can be tied to the workplace. Since Jan. 1, 2022, it has recorded at least four more officers killed by COVID-19.

Boise State’s Jorgensen questions whether the pandemic should be considered as a factor when weighing whether policing is more dangerous today and in previous years. He pointed to a recent study that found food workers and other essential workers, such as in manufacturing and transportation, may suffer higher COVID-19 infection rates than emergency responders, such as police.

“Over the past two years, I’ve found it rather disturbing seeing police officers not wear masks when they should be and protest against vaccine mandates, etc.,” Jorgensen said. “So, if we’re going to say that COVID is causing policing to be the most dangerous it has been in nearly 100 years, we have to say the same thing about a bunch of other occupations. For example, I can say that, because of COVID, being a professor hasn’t been this dangerous since the Spanish flu epidemic. And that just sounds weird to me.”

COVID-19 law enforcement

A victim of COVID-19, Houston Police Department Senior Officer John Wilbanks, 55, was buried Oct. 18, 2021, in Texas. He became the second Houston Police Department officer killed by the virus. City of Houston Office of Emergency Management photo.

Georgia State’s Johnson said other data could be combined to determine whether policing is more dangerous today. These could include trends in assaults on officers, measurements of workplace stress during the pandemic, law enforcement suicides, deaths from traffic accidents, and unprovoked or ambush attacks on law enforcement.

“Maybe we don’t say the job is ‘the most dangerous’ but with the circumstances of a more deadly year and the circumstances under which officers operate are much more dangerous now,” Johnson said.

There was a sharp rise in the number of officers who were feloniously killed in 2021 — 73, the highest number since the attacks of 9/11, according to FBI Director Christopher Wray.

An FBI awareness report for law enforcement departments nationwide that was obtained by Coffee or Die showed unprovoked and ambush attacks nearly tripled over 2020’s numbers — from 11 to 32, as of Nov. 31, 2021.

And December saw several more officers killed in a combination of unprovoked and ambush attacks.

Michael “Mike” Gale Garbo funeral

Cheri Oz, the special agent in charge of DEA’s Phoenix Field Division, presents the flag to daughter, Alexis, and widow, Vida, of US Drug Enforcement Administration Supervisory Special Agent Michael “Mike” Gale Garbo on Oct. 8, 2021, at his funeral. Garbo was killed in the line of duty Oct. 4, 2021. US Customs and Border Protection image.

Johnson said the rise in felonious deaths is concerning “but it is also anomaly” because the 10-year average for these fatalities is roughly 50 annually.

“Anomalous spikes like this do occur occasionally but are short-lived,” he continued. “I don’t expect the increase we saw in 2021 to be repeated in 2022. The current 2022 numbers are lower than the 2021 numbers were at this point in the year, which is still very early.”

Boise State’s Jorgensen wonders if the spike in ambush and unprovoked killings partly stems from “public vengeance” triggered by the criminal justice system’s inability to hold some officers accountable for using excessive force on suspects.

grim year 2021

NYPD officer Anastasios Tsakos was killed while directing traffic on April 27, 2021. New York Police Department photo.

NYPD officer Anastasios Tsakos was killed while directing traffic early Tuesday, April 27, 2021. New York Police Department photo.

The National Law Enforcement Officers Memorial Fund’s report on 2021 deaths also pointed to the rise in traffic-related fatalities. The organization’s preliminary report tallied 58 cops who lost their lives in traffic accidents last year.

That was a 38% hike from 2020 and it was paced by rising numbers of officers working alongside a roadway who were struck and killed by other vehicles.

“Tragically, struck-by fatalities have increased by an extraordinary 93% over last year,” the authors wrote.

Read Next: Feds Charge 4 for Robbery and Slaying of House Hunting LAPD Cop

Joshua is a staff writer for Coffee or Die Magazine. He has covered the 75th anniversary of D-Day in France, multinational military exercises in Germany, and civil unrest during the 2020 riots in Minneapolis that followed the death of George Floyd. Born and raised in small-town South Dakota, Joshua grew up playing football and soccer before serving as a forward observer in the US Army. After leaving the service, he earned his CrossFit Level 1 certificate and worked as a personal trainer while earning his paramedic license. Joshua went on to work in paramedicine for more than five years, much of that time in the North Minneapolis area, before transitioning to a career in multimedia journalism. Joshua is married, has two children, and is currently pursuing his bachelor’s degree in multimedia journalism. His creative outlets include Skovlund Photography and Concentrated Emotion, which is where he publishes poetry focused on his life experiences.
More from Coffee or Die Magazine
With the US and India deepening their military ties, the Himalayan mountain chain marks another geopolitical flashpoint with China.
With its iconic folding wings and six machine guns, the Corsair proved exceptionally lethal in World War II and beyond.
Letter bombs mailed to the US Embassy in Madrid and Spanish government offices triggered elevated security at Naval Station Rota.
The Air Force will officially reveal the replacement for the B-2 stealth bomber on Friday, Dec. 2.
When he was released, after 28 months as a prisoner, he thought he would face charges. Instead, he was told he’d won the highest award for valor.
A Connecticut man faces up to 20 years behind bars for trying to join Islamic State group terrorists.
The annual matchup was first played in 1890 and has since become something much bigger — and more important — than just a football game.
A blaze erupted on the aircraft carrier Abraham Lincoln, injuring nine sailors before it was extinguished.
The encounter highlighted a trend of increasingly aggressive Chinese military behavior in the region.
Marines and sailors see the landing assault ships Tripoli and America as light carriers.