Opinion: Marvel Canceled ‘The Punisher’ Logo for Deeply Flawed Reasons

Punisher Hed 1

Marvel is releasing a new Punisher comic in March but has changed the iconic skull logo in an attempt to distance itself from police and other groups who have adopted it. Composite by Coffee or Die Magazine.

An all-new Punisher series is coming to the Marvel Universe in March of 2022, and with it comes a major change to the vigilante superhero’s iconic logo. In a strange step back from the well-established symbol, Marvel has decided to distance the company from fans who opt for the elongated skull over Superman’s “S” or the Bat symbol. The move was apparently a long time coming.

Following the Jan. 6, 2021, attack on the US Capitol, images surfaced of rioters wearing the Punisher’s skull. Two days later, in an interview with Syfy Wire, Punisher writer Garth Ennis condemned the appropriation of the logo.

“The people wearing the logo in this context are kidding themselves, just like the police officers who wore it over the summer,” Ennis said. “What they actually want is to wear an apparently scary symbol on a T-shirt, throw their weight around a bit, then go home to the wife and kids and resume everyday life. They’ve thought no harder about the Punisher symbol than the halfwits I saw [on Jan. 6], the ones waving the Stars & Stripes while invading the Capitol building.”

police response Capitol building

Police clashed with supporters of President Donald Trump outside the Capitol before the protesters breached the police line and then stormed the building during the “Stop the Steal” rally in Washington, DC, Jan. 6. Photo by Joseph Andrew Lee/Coffee or Die Magazine.

Ennis is right to criticize the criminals who dragged his character’s logo through the mud by attacking American democracy, but he’s wrong in his sweeping condemnation of police officers.

Frank Castle, aka the Punisher, is a beloved comic book antihero who gets bloodied in the name of justice and revenge. He does what other superheroes won’t, getting his hands (and morals) dirty along the way. A veteran of the Marine Corps who takes on the mob after they murder his family, Castle is a damaged soul hellbent on stopping organized crime by any means necessary. Like the Boondock Saints or virtually any Clint Eastwood character, the Punisher is not unique in his story of vigilante justice. By scrapping the iconic logo altogether, Marvel is missing the mark.

I used to associate the superhero’s skull with Navy SEALs. Cadillac Platoon of SEAL Team 3 was the first military unit to widely adopt Marvel’s vigilante symbol when they began spray-painting the Punisher logo on their vehicles and body armor during their 2006 deployment to Ramadi, Iraq. Despite frogmen making the fictional character’s logo cool among real-life warriors, it only made sense for Marines to follow suit. After all, Castle was a Marine.

Punisher

Frank Castle’s iconic Punisher skull made the jump from comic books to real battlefields when it was adopted by SEAL Team 3. Screenshot from YouTube.

Frank Castle’s iconic Punisher skull made the jump from comic books to real battlefields when it was adopted by SEAL Team 3. Screenshot from YouTube.

When I enlisted into the Marine Corps in 2009, the Punisher logo was still everywhere in the military. Junior Marines sported T-shirts that combined the iconic skull with cheesy slogans. A significant number of the Ford Mustangs and Jeep Wranglers that filled the barracks’ parking lot had Punisher decals on the rear bumper. The Post Exchange sold water bottles, hats, and every other kind of junk a new Marine might waste money on with the logo of Marvel’s most violent superhero. The only symbol more prevalent on Camp Lejeune was the USMC’s own Eagle, Globe, and Anchor. But even in 2009, the Punisher skull was falling out of vogue and the majority of Marines still brandishing the unique skull with long teeth were those furthest removed from combat.

A decade after watching the logo’s popularity wane in the military, I encountered a second wave of Punisher fanatics. The day after swearing in as a police officer, I found myself experiencing a bit of déjà vu. Like the parking lot of the infantry barracks, the parking lot of the police precinct had more than one Punisher logo dotting the bumpers of officers’ personal vehicles.

After a reflexive eye roll from seeing the played-out tough guy skull again, my next thought was that Marvel’s ultraviolent vigilante didn’t mesh with the values of law enforcement. Frank Castle subverts the law; police officers uphold it. While I was right in the eye roll, I was wrong in my assumption of what cops saw in the comic book character.

Chris Kyle, The Punisher

Chris Kyle wearing the Punisher logo on his body armor in Ramadi, Iraq. Photo courtesy of Kevin Lacz.

Police officers who own a Punisher hat or sticker don’t actually fancy themselves vigilante antiheroes, just like people wearing Superman shirts don’t mistake themselves for the laser-gazing man of steel. In reality, people whose job involves exposure to violence on a regular basis (cops) can better relate to the gritty Marvel superhero than to an alien in tights who lifts trains in the air or a web-shooting teenager dressed as a spider. Most superheroes are a little more PG and a little less relatable to the men and women who carry a gun and walk a beat.

Officers with Punisher decals on their car are obviously not condoning subversion of the law, and to infer that they are is irresponsible and small-minded. The only thing they’re guilty of is ruining their own vehicle’s paint job with a stupid decal. Those same officers Ennis loops in with “halfwits” dedicate their lives to upholding the law. In fact, they’re the same people who risked their lives on Jan. 6 to stop the very criminals Ennis associates them with. In 2021, 487 officers sacrificed their lives demonstrating an unparalleled level of devotion to the law.

police

Police officers saluting during a funeral for a fallen officer. Photo courtesy of Pixabay/Igor Ovsyannykov.

Marvel may have felt the heat of cancel culture and taken the easy shot of saying police and service members who like the fictional character of Frank Castle are missing the point of the comic, but what’s far sillier than a cop fantasizing about being able to stop criminals without the restraints of procedures and legal loopholes is Marvel trying to distance its ultraviolent, trigger-happy superhero from the real heroes who demonstrate restraint and professionalism in the face of violence every day.

Marvel’s move to abandon the logo allows the criminals who attacked the Capitol to win. No longer will the complex comic book character be associated with real heroes like SEALs and police officers who championed the symbol long before January 2021. Instead, Marvel easily submitted to the conspiracy theorists and extremists who commandeered it.

Read Next: We Must Remember That More Veterans Defended Against the Capitol Breach Than Participated in It

Mac Caltrider is a senior staff writer for Coffee or Die Magazine. He is a US Marine Corps veteran and a former police officer. Caltrider earned his bachelor’s degree in history and now reads anything he can get his hands on. He is also the creator of Pipes & Pages, a site intended to increase readership among enlisted troops. Caltrider spends most of his time reading, writing, and waging a one-man war against premature hair loss.
More from Coffee or Die Magazine
A new Marine Corps physical training uniform will have shorter shorts than previous versions, but they won’t be as short as the long-banned, skin-tight, still-beloved “silkies.”
Not enough fuel, too many miles to go over open ocean, and the aircrew was flying into a spot they call the Black Hole.
During ferocious fighting in Anzio, Italy, Harold Nelson’s commander wrote to Nelson’s mother that he’d been put in for a Silver Star. Now 107, Nelson finally got it.
After a week of competition at Fort Bragg, North Carolina, four squads will travel to Washington, DC, for the last event of the Army-wide Best Squad competition — an interview panel with Pentagon leaders, including the sergeant major of the Army.
After more than seven months of full-scale warfare, Russian gas still flows through Ukraine to Europe each day.
A fleet of US Coast Guard and Army National Guard helicopters has descended on hurricane-ravaged Sanibel Island.
About one in five C-130s in the Air Force is out of service as older C-130Hs, which were first introduced in the 1970s, are grounded to have their propellers inspected.
The aircraft carrier Gerald R. Ford will spend at least one more day in Virginia.
Ford’s technological glitches included propulsion problems, hinky elevators, and gremlins in the catapults.
Francis Ford Coppola’s 1979 Vietnam War epic “Apocalypse Now” is one of the most recognizable war movies ever made, yet few fans are familiar with the insane story behind its production.